It’s apparently National Absurdity Day (is that really a thing here?) and that’s a coincidence because I’m increasingly struck by the peculiarity of the British higher education system with its four separate regulatory systems, each with its own success measures, reporting requirements and strategic priorities all packed into such a modestly sized country – about 600 miles top to bottom! This regulatory diversity matters especially in the context of this week’s reporting of the OfS pushing English universities towards mergers, suggesting that regional consolidation might ease financial pressures. Yet evidence coming from Wales would appear to tell a very different story. Despite promises to maintain provision, merged institutions often end up closing smaller campuses, impacting hard on local economies and communities (see, for example, Newport’s closure and the proposal to shift Lampeter’s humanities provision to Carmarthen). I’ve watched this pattern play out differently in my region’s further education sector. Portsmouth’s colleges merged while initially maintaining separate identities and campuses and the Chichester College Group expanded thoughtfully, keeping local college names and focuses. But, universities face distinct pressures – specialist research facilities, academic cultures and civic roles create different challenges than those facing colleges.
It’s ironic that in the 1960s, when only 6% of school leavers went to university, geographical spread was apparently very carefully planned. The University Grants Committee, which led these efforts, chose locations to serve communities needing HE provision. Cultural traditions, transport links and economic needs were all apparently weighed up in the mix. For example, reports suggest that Colchester got Essex University instead of Chelmsford partly to help build a self-contained academic community away from London’s pull. Yet, with student numbers far higher now and many applicants preferring to study from home, we seem to risk losing that regional distribution – not through planning but through its apparent absence.
In any case, it would seem that the numbers behind merger savings rarely add up without campus closures. In actual fact, running one big institution probably proves no cheaper than running two smaller ones, according to some experts. Culture clashes tend to derail the careful plans that may be put in place to apparently manage mergers and the real financial gains probably only really come from selling buildings and cutting jobs. And this then creates a paradox. More students want or need to study near home, yet financial pressure pushes universities to cluster in cities. So, in reality, when campuses close, communities lose more than teaching provision. They lose jobs, cultural events, local spending and opportunities for those young people who probably need them most. Legal experts who handle these deals tell us mergers only work with genuine strategic benefits – complementary courses, shared academic strengths, or clear geographical logic and financial pressure alone rarely justifies the complexity and cost of joining institutions. Nevertheless, current policy seems to push financial metrics above strategic sense.
Each nation has a slightly different lens on current priorities it seems: England’s OfS focuses on financial metrics, Wales emphasises civic duties, Scotland prioritises collaboration and Northern Ireland follows its own path. So, in essence, we have four systems and regulatory approaches, with hardly any joined-up thinking about such questions of regional provision. The 1960s expansion may not have been perfect – For example, Coleraine’s selection over Derry apparently sparked protests that still echo today. But at least it seemed to follow a plan – however flawed it was. Today, we risk drift by default, with the prospect of closed campuses and merged institutions leaving cold spots in provision and how does all of this align with a continued emphasis on widening participation, which remains a declared priority in some quarters?
Recent media commentary suggests that those who’ve led successful mergers tend to emphasise timing and preparation as being key as opposed to waiting until an institution faces a crisis, which obviously limits options and bargaining power. But acting too hastily, without proper board scrutiny and stakeholder engagement, risks damaging both institutions. It’s a delicate balance that needs more than spreadsheet solutions. Plus, alternatives may exist. Shared services, for example, could cut costs while maintaining local identity. Regional teaching partnerships might preserve access. However, these ideas need coordinated support across government departments. Transport links, housing, health placements, and regional development all affect where universities can sustainably operate. So, yes, the current push for mergers could solve some narrow balance sheet problems. But without serious thought about place, purpose, and provision, it arguably risks damaging the communities that universities exist to serve.
Therefore, we need much more than just merger proposals. We need a plan for the HE sector that considers geography as well as economics, one that recognises how universities shape communities, not just their students’ future careers. Maintaining four regulatory systems might seem absurd, but losing hard-won regional provision through unplanned drift would seem complete madness.
If you’re mulling over these issues for your institution, an external perspective could help map the options, offer a fresh perspective or, at the very least, help you untangle some of these questions.
