The courage to tell the truth: what student representatives…

…really need from senior leaders

As a new group of student representatives assumes office this summer, I’ve been reflecting on what we owe them. Not the simple platitudes about student voice and partnership, but something inherently more challenging and valuable: the truth about what is actually achievable within the current confines of available resources.

During my work with various institutions on multiple projects and through general sector observations, I’ve seen senior leaders grappling with difficult choices. The Mental Health Counsellor versus the Academic Skills Tutor. The subsidised sports facilities versus the hardship fund. The extra marking time versus employability support. These aren’t just abstract policy debates, they are real trade-offs that impact actual students.

Yet when those same leaders meet with incoming student officers, the conversation can often shift. We may suddenly return to the language of aspiration and ambition. We may nod along to manifestos promising “more and better” across every aspect of the student experience. We can often speak in careful euphemisms about “challenging financial contexts” whilst avoiding the specifics.

This kindness, in my view, is badly misplaced because it encourages student representatives towards frustration and failure, and more than anything else, it possibly wastes the chance for genuine partnership when institutions need it most.

I’ve previously observed talented student officers spend months pushing against doors that will never actually open. Not because senior leaders didn’t care, but because no one had the courage to explain why those doors were locked. The unfortunate outcome of this might be that students who could have been powerful advocates for difficult but necessary changes instead become frustrated critics of a system they don’t fully understand.

The alternative requires senior leaders to do something which could be perceived as highly uncomfortable: bringing student representatives into the room where the real decisions are made. And I don’t mean the sanitised version of budget planning, but the actual conversations about priorities and trade-offs.

This may involve sharing the data that keeps senior leadership teams awake at night. The demographic breakdown of progression figures. The waiting times for mental health services. The proportion of students taking on debt to pay for basic necessities. The choice between maintaining small class sizes and keeping the library open on weekends.

Institutional student experience strategies can be flawed because they assume resources that are simply not available. In such contexts, the gap between aspiration and reality isn’t just a planning issue but a partnership one too. How can we expect student representatives to advocate effectively for their peers if they don’t understand what is actually possible or accessible?

I’ve usually found student representatives to be quite pragmatic when given the full overview. They can often quickly understand that perfect is the enemy of good and they can differentiate quickly between what would be nice and what is essential. In fact, they often have better ideas about where to direct limited resources than senior teams who are three steps removed from the student experience.

So instead of promising expanded counselling services that cannot be delivered, we might share actual data on demand and waiting times. Student Officers could then help develop a peer support programme that might triple the number of students receiving some form of mental health support, at a fraction of the cost of extra professional staff.

Honest conversations about library budget cuts could lead to a student-led campaign that secures additional funding from an external source, something that could never happen if the original plan were to quietly absorb the cuts while maintaining the pretence that nothing had changed.

Instead of lowering expectations or abandoning ambition, ambition could be directed towards achievable changes. Student representatives elected on platforms of “more and better” could well become influential advocates for “different and sustainable” once they understand why that shift is necessary.

I think timing is important here too in that these discussions should probably take place in the first month of student officers assuming their roles, not after they’ve been six months into campaigns that were unlikely to succeed. Being honest early on could avoid later letdowns and foster genuine collaboration.

I recognise this requires vulnerable leadership in ways that don’t necessarily come naturally. Admitting an institution can’t fulfil everything that students need might feel like some kind of professional failure. Yet the alternative is allowing student representatives to discover these limitations through bitter experience, which is surely far worse for everyone involved.

The institutions I observe in the sector that foster the strongest student partnerships are perhaps those where senior leaders have perhaps been honest about limitations from the outset, where student representatives understand not just what the institution does, but why it makes its choices, where student voice is genuinely valued because it is actually informed by reality.

As this year’s student representatives begin their terms, they perhaps deserve more than just our good intentions, but also the truth about what is possible, what is not, and why. They perhaps deserve to be regarded as partners in tackling institutional challenges, not as customers to be managed or advocates to be appeased.

So the question for senior leaders isn’t perhaps whether you can afford to have these honest conversations but rather whether you can afford not to.