On the institutional memory problem…

…and why universities keep learning the same lessons.

The Quality Assurance Agency was established in 1997 to settle what were then described as “increasingly vexatious questions” about quality assessment in higher education. Nearly three decades later, those questions feel remarkably familiar. Each new framework promises to address the limitations of its predecessor, yet universities find themselves repeatedly wading through similar challenges with what can sometimes feel like limited institutional wisdom to draw upon.

This pattern might suggest something more fundamental than policy design flaws. It could point to a deeper organisational challenge: universities may be systematically losing their capacity to learn from their own experience.

When experience walks out the door

Consider what happens when a seasoned academic registrar retires, taking with them a decade of experience. Or when budget pressures force the departure of academic developers who understood why certain quality enhancement approaches succeeded while others failed. These departures might represent more than staffing changes. They could constitute a form of institutional amnesia.

The current wave of restructuring across the sector may be exacerbating this challenge in ways we haven’t fully recognised. When universities reduce their workforce under pressure and at pace, they might inadvertently be depleting their organisational memory just when they need it most. The person who could explain why a particular committee structure was established, or how a previous regulatory transition was managed, may no longer be available to inform current decisions.

The knowledge that lives between the lines

Institutional memory isn’t simply about documented processes or archived committee minutes. It encompasses the contextual understanding that makes policies work in practice, the informal networks that actually drive change, the cultural nuances that determine which approaches will gain traction and the hard-won insights about what works within a specific institutional context.

This knowledge often exists in what we might call the institutional “middle”, among senior administrators, experienced academic developers and long-serving academics who have witnessed multiple change cycles. These colleagues typically understand not just what was implemented, but why certain decisions were made, how various stakeholders responded and what unintended consequences emerged.

When these roles are restructured away or when experienced staff choose to leave due to worry or uncertainty engendered by a perceived financial precarity, universities might be losing more than operational capacity. They could be severing connections to their own learning history.

The reinvention trap

Without access to institutional memory, universities may find themselves caught in cycles of reinvention. A new quality framework arrives and teams begin developing implementation strategies that feel innovative but might actually echo approaches tried unsuccessfully five years earlier. Committee structures are redesigned without understanding why previous configurations evolved as they did. Engagement strategies are developed without awareness of what has already been tested with different stakeholder groups.

This pattern might explain why quality enhancement initiatives sometimes feel familiar to long-serving staff, even when they’re presented as fresh approaches. It could also illuminate why some universities seem to be able to work through regulatory changes more smoothly than others; perhaps they’ve managed to preserve and access their institutional learning more effectively.

The timing challenge

The current moment presents a particularly acute version of this challenge. Just as universities are grappling with another round of quality assurance reform, many are simultaneously managing significant organisational change. The Office for Students’ continuing evolution of its approach to quality regulation coincides with financial pressures that have prompted restructuring across professional services and academic departments.

This timing might not be coincidental bad luck. It could represent a systemic vulnerability in how universities manage change. When external pressures mount, institutions often focus on immediate operational challenges, potentially underestimating the longer-term implications of losing experiential knowledge.

Learning to remember

Some universities might be developing more conscious approaches to preserving institutional memory. This could involve creating more systematic ways of capturing the reasoning behind decisions, not just the decisions themselves. It might mean establishing mentoring relationships that transfer contextual knowledge alongside technical skills. It could involve developing institutional narratives that help new staff understand not just current processes, but how and why they evolved.

The most resilient institutions might be those that treat institutional memory as a strategic asset rather than a by-product of longevity. They may be finding ways to embed learning from previous experiences into their organisational structures, creating systems that can absorb and retain wisdom even as personnel change.

Questions worth asking

Rather than simply implementing the next quality framework, universities might benefit from examining their own capacity for institutional learning. Do they understand why previous approaches succeeded or failed? Can they identify patterns in their own organisational responses to change? Have they preserved the contextual knowledge that could inform current decisions?

These questions become more pressing as the sector faces continued uncertainty. Quality assurance frameworks will likely continue evolving and financial pressures may well persist. Universities that can learn from their own experience rather than repeatedly learning the same lessons might be better positioned to grapple with whatever changes lie ahead.

The challenge isn’t just about getting the next quality framework right. It might be about developing the institutional capacity to get better at change itself. In a sector where the only constant seems to be reform, the ability to learn from experience could become a crucial competitive advantage.

Perhaps most importantly, preserving institutional memory isn’t simply about efficiency or avoiding past mistakes. It’s perhaps rather more about maintaining connection to the accumulated wisdom that makes each university distinctive. In an era of increasing standardisation and external oversight, that institutional distinctiveness might be more valuable than ever.