On Student Agency in HE

Are HE providers really listening to their students? This is a question that has come up in sector media over the last couple of weeks and higher education appears to be at a moment of reflection in relation to it. While universities have long championed principles of student involvement, recent experiences at several institutions suggest that genuine student agency, rather than mere consultation, may provide routes to more responsive institutional practices. Two recent examples from ATU Sligo Students’ Union and London South Bank University (LSBU), which have received recent coverage, demonstrate different approaches to meaningful student partnership that deserve our attention.

Reconsidering the Path From Student Voice to Student Agency

For decades, universities have perhaps operated under an implicit assumption that they know best what students need. As such, student voice initiatives, feedback mechanisms, and committee representation have become standard practice across the sector. Yet, despite these structures, we might wonder whether institutions sometimes maintain systems and policies that reflect organisational convenience rather than student reality.

What seems to differentiate the two approaches highlighted in the ATU Sligo Students’ Union advocacy piece and the piece on LSBU’s late submission policy change is a subtle shift in philosophy: a movement from viewing students primarily as beneficiaries of university services to recognising them as potential partners with valuable expertise derived from their lived experience. Certainly, both of these initiatives highlight the potential benefits of involving students more deeply in decision-making processes.

Reflections from Practice

At LSBU, what may have once seemed like a radical change – removing penalties for late submissions – emerged from listening to students’ lived experiences rather than adhering to sector assumptions. As Moss, Ransom, Adams, and Myles-Brown describe in their recent article for WONKE on this change of practice, the team found that students appeared to be overwhelmed rather than tactical in their approach to deadlines. Their careful monitoring suggested that removing marking caps for late submissions did not lead to widespread deadline avoidance, as some might have feared. Instead, it seemed to reduce the administrative burden while potentially improving outcomes, particularly for first-year and historically underrepresented students.

Similarly, observations from a piece in the same outlet by Dáire Martin at ATU Sligo Students’ Union regarding co-designing student support services have raised questions about whether institutions that design services for students rather than with them might miss valuable opportunities for improvement. When students join conversations after primary decisions have been made, their contributions may become limited to refinement instead of helping shape foundational design choices, the piece argues.

Reflecting on Consultation Practices

 What these examples invite us to consider are the potential limitations of consultation as our primary methodology. Consultation often occurs within parameters established by the institution, with decision-making authority largely retained by those framing the questions. As such, it tends to focus on preferences within existing and often formalised frameworks rather than opening space to question the frameworks themselves.

A more involved approach to co-creation might require sharing some decision-making authority from earlier stages. This could mean being open to outcomes that occasionally challenge institutional traditions or established ways of working. It might involve creating spaces where students can participate in identifying the problems worth solving, not just evaluating proposed solutions to challenges predefined by the institution.

Gently Questioning Accepted Practice

 Some principles may become so embedded in university practice that we start to question their purpose or efficacy. Late submission penalties could be viewed as one such example—widely accepted across the sector as necessary, yet perhaps not sufficiently examined for their effectiveness. When LSBU carefully tested this assumption, they found that their students appeared to engage appropriately with deadlines even without the threat of academic penalties.

This experience raises thoughtful questions about other practices that could benefit from similar reconsideration:

  • Assessment methods that may favour certain ways of demonstrating knowledge
  • Support services that are primarily structured around institutional organisation rather than student journeys.
  • Communication approaches that are likely designed more for administrative efficiency than for student effectiveness.
  • Timetabling systems that may sometimes (often?) prioritise room utilisation over optimal learning patterns.

 

Tentative Steps from Theory to Practice

Moving from consultation to a more authentic partnership likely requires much thoughtful consideration of structural and cultural dimensions. Institutions might reflect on approaches such as:

  • Considering shared governance – Exploring mechanisms through which students can contribute more meaningfully to strategic decisions, rather than merely feeding into pre-defined agendas.
  • Thoughtful resource allocation: Considering whether allocating resources for student-led initiatives might foster valuable innovation.
  • Co-design explorations – Possibly experimenting with design thinking approaches that start by understanding student experiences in conjunction with institutional perspectives
  • Recognising different forms of expertise: acknowledging that students may have valuable insights into their own learning experiences that can enhance professional and academic knowledge.
  • Inclusive evaluation frameworks: exploring whether success metrics might sometimes incorporate student-defined outcomes alongside traditional institutional indicators.

 

Possible Wider Implications

 When institutions find ways to trust students as partners, the benefits might extend beyond specific policy improvements. Trust often generates more reciprocal trust. Students who see evidence that their input has helped shape meaningful change may become more engaged with institutional processes. Support services designed with student involvement are likely to be used more effectively.

Perhaps one of the more meaningful aspects of partnership approaches is the subtle message they may convey about institutional values. They could suggest that providers view learning as a somewhat collaborative endeavour rather than primarily a hierarchical transaction. This shift in relationship might be as valuable as any specific policy change.

Considering Cultural Dimensions

 It also seems possible that significant barriers to more authentic student partnership may be as cultural as they are structural. Exploring this area may invite us to examine assumptions about whether institutional knowledge should always take precedence over student experience. It might require us to be open to considering solutions that could initially seem somewhat impractical or challenging to implement.

For those of us in senior leadership positions accustomed to consultant reports and sector benchmarking, turning more directly to students as a significant source of improvement ideas may feel like unfamiliar territory. Yet, early evidence from providers attempting this approach suggests that working through this initial uncertainty might occasionally lead to valuable insights that may not emerge through more traditional methods.

Thoughtful Steps Forward

As the sector grapples with ongoing challenges related to student satisfaction, retention, and outcomes, it may be worth considering whether one somewhat still untapped resource could be the insights of students themselves, not merely as occasional consultees but as more systematic and substantial contributors to shaping various aspects of their educational experience.

The thoughtful approaches being tested by institutions willing to question certain established practices and explore different forms of partnership with their students might offer a valuable example worth further exploration. They suggest a model where enhancement becomes something created not merely for students but sometimes with them. Such approaches warrant further careful evaluation, but early indications certainly suggest they may deserve our collective reflection.