The current challenge
Recent sector commentary has raised an intriguing question about mutual advocacy in HE – whether HE providers could and should do more to champion each other’s contributions. However, barriers to such advocacy are probably deeply embedded in our sector’s structure rather than in attitudes or an unwillingness to collaborate.
Consider research funding, for example. When Russell Group and post-92 universities compete for the same limited grants, could we expect vice-chancellors to champion each other’s bids? Similarly, student recruitment drives institutions to emphasise their unique offerings, often implicitly positioning themselves against their neighbours.
Learning from crisis
Yet, these structural constraints haven’t always prevented meaningful collaboration. During the pandemic, providers shared teaching resources, research facilities and expertise without hesitation. This wasn’t just crisis management – it demonstrated our latent capacity in the sector for mutual support.
The question, then, isn’t whether HE providers can support each other – we know they can. Instead, we could ask what conditions enable this collaboration and how we might replicate them beyond times of crisis.
Patterns of success
From my consultancy work across multiple institutions, I’ve observed that successful cross-institutional advocacy typically emerges in three contexts: when facing shared external threats, when working on pre-competitive research, and when addressing regional economic challenges. Each context offers lessons for building sustained collaboration.
Take the example of regional skills partnerships. When universities in the Northeast joined forces to address skills gaps in emerging technologies, they created more impact than they could have achieved alone. Their success stemmed from recognising that the region’s economic growth would benefit all institutions – a principle that could apply more broadly.
Addressing structural barriers
However, we need to address the metrics that drive competition to make mutual advocacy sustainable. League tables, TEF outcomes, and research excellence frameworks – while valuable tools – currently discourage institutions from highlighting others’ strengths. A vice-chancellor who praises another institution’s teaching excellence might, for example, risk questions from their own board about relative performance.
The solution isn’t perhaps to dismantle these performance measures, they look like they are here to stay, but to broaden them. What if institutional success metrics included evidence of sector-wide contribution? This might include joint programmes, shared facilities, or support for other institutions’ initiatives. The recent civic university agreements show how institutions can pursue individual excellence and collective benefit. The new Access and Participation Plans have started to recognise this, partially focusing on increasing access to HE for student groups with low participation rates through regional provider collaboration.
Learning from others
We might also learn from other sectors. NHS trusts appear to face some similar tensions between competition and collaboration, yet they have developed frameworks for sharing good practice and resources. Their experience suggests that formal collaboration structures – backed by funding and accountability measures – could help balance institutional and sector-wide interests.
Moving forward
For sector leaders, this presents an opportunity and a challenge. The opportunity lies in redefining institutional success to encompass individual achievement and sector-wide contribution. The challenge, perhaps, is to do this while maintaining individual provider distinctiveness and managing board expectations.
From my experience, three steps could help move us forward. First, we need to identify areas where collaboration clearly benefits all parties – much like the regional skills partnerships mentioned earlier. Second, we could develop metrics that recognise and reward cross-institutional support. Finally, we could create more forums where institutions can share challenges and solutions without fear of competitive disadvantage. This definitely happens ad hoc way in some sector groups like GuildHE and Universities UK and in networks like AdvanceHE and QAA’s PVC networks, etc. But not necessarily formally and systematically.
Making change happen
Cross-institutional advocacy requires more than just goodwill, though; it needs structural change and clear incentives. So, until we address the underlying drivers of sector competition, calls for mutual support will probably remain aspirational rather than practical.
Yet the potential benefits would warrant this effort. A more collaborative sector could be better positioned to face shared challenges, from funding pressures to changing student needs. It could also present a more compelling investment case, showing how different institutions combine to create a robust and diverse HE system.
For those of us who have helped lead institutions through periods of intense competition, this may seem counter-intuitive. However, our experience also shows that universities achieve more when they work together than when they stand alone. The challenge now is to turn these moments of collaboration from exceptions into standard practice.
If you’re interested in discussing how your institution could develop its collaborative practices or require any other external project support, do get in touch.
